Ready to demo the most-used, most scalable data catalog on the market?
Data catalogs help organizations manage their data assets more effectively, with data.world and Atlan standing out as leading solutions in this space. While both platforms provide core data cataloging capabilities—including discovery, lineage tracking, and governance—they approach these challenges differently.
Data.world differentiates itself with a knowledge graph foundation that treats knowledge as a first-class citizen, enabling organizations to build connections between technical metadata and business context. Its AI Context Engine enhances the accuracy of AI applications, while its open standards approach provides flexibility. Atlan emphasizes dynamic access controls and self-service capabilities that appeal to technical personas, with particular strength in rapid deployment for data engineers. Both platforms support modern data stacks, but each has carved out a unique position in the market based on their architectural foundations and user experience priorities.
Atlan and data.world, at a glance:
Atlan offers dynamic access control and self-service features that appeal to data engineers and technical users
data.world provides a knowledge graph architecture with AI-powered capabilities that bridge technical and business knowledge
Evaluating data catalog vendors? Use the Data Catalog RFI Template to evaluate options and make a data-driven decision.
data.world: Knowledge graph driven data catalog
data.world is a cloud-native data catalog and governance platform built on a unique knowledge graph foundation that represents metadata as interconnected nodes and edges. This architecture creates a "single source of data knowledge" by integrating diverse data sources and business concepts, allowing organizations to visualize how assets like database tables connect to BI dashboards or AI models.
The knowledge graph effectively bridges technical data with business context by linking glossary terms, policies, and technical assets in a common language, which significantly enhances search and discovery capabilities. Beyond its technical architecture, data.world emphasizes collaboration with an intuitive, user-centric interface that enables all stakeholders to contribute descriptions, participate in discussions, and share analyses.
The platform combines essential catalog functions with AI automation to classify assets, suggest metadata, and detect relationships, reducing manual effort while accelerating time-to-value through AI-assisted search and cloud-based delivery that eliminates infrastructure concerns.
data.world’s knowledge graph architecture provides superior search and discovery capabilities compared to Atlan. See what data.world users say about the platform.
Features and benefits of data.world
Knowledge graph and discovery
data.world’s most distinctive feature is its knowledge graph architecture. All data assets, business terms, and their relationships are stored in a graph model, giving users a unified, connected view of their data ecosystem. This means you can navigate from a data source to the reports that use it, to the business glossary terms that define it, in a seamless graph.
The knowledge graph approach dramatically enhances search and discovery. Because data.world understands the relationships between things, users can perform a search and get results that aren’t just exact matches, but also relevant connections. For example, a search for “customer revenue” might return not only datasets with “customer” in the name, but also a KPI definition of revenue in the business glossary and a dashboard that analyzes customer revenue. This context-rich search helps users discover insights that a simple keyword match would miss.
data.world embeds AI into its cataloging process. It can automatically enrich metadata by scanning data assets and suggesting additional tags, descriptions, or classifications. For instance, if a dataset contains email addresses, the platform’s AI might tag it as containing “PII” (personally identifiable information).
he platform provides AI-assisted search and recommendations to users as well. If you’re looking at a particular dataset, data.world might suggest related datasets or relevant glossary terms based on patterns it has learned.
data.world prides itself on a friendly, accessible interface that caters to a broad audience. The platform’s design is clean and modern, often noted for being easy to navigate. Non-technical users can browse and search for data without needing to know SQL or have deep data knowledge.
Much like a social network for data, data.world enables users to collaborate directly within the catalog. They can comment on datasets, ask questions, and share knowledge in context. If someone has a useful SQL query or analysis using a dataset, they can save and share it on the platform, effectively turning the catalog into a community knowledge base. Data.world also supports projects and workspaces where teams can organize resources for a particular analysis or initiative. All of these features foster a strong data community within an organization, where users help each other and collectively enhance the documentation and understanding of data. This collaborative environment is a key benefit – it means the catalog isn’t just maintained by a few data librarians, but is actively enriched by its user community.
Broad data source support and integration
data.world is capable of connecting to a wide array of data sources, whether they are structured databases, semi-structured files, or unstructured data sets. Companies dealing with everything from relational databases to JSON files or even APIs can bring those assets into data.world’s catalog.
When data.world ingests datasets, it can perform data profiling – analyzing the data to capture statistics and detect anomalies. Users can view profile information such as value distributions, missing values, or outlier values for dataset columns. These profiling insights help users quickly understand a dataset’s quality and contents without manual inspection. For instance, seeing that a “Date” field has 5% nulls and some out-of-range values gives immediate cues about data quality.
data.world provides various connectors and APIs to integrate with existing data tools and workflows. It supports standards-based query languages (for example, SPARQL for the knowledge graph, and also SQL for querying certain connected data).
Data lineage and governance
Thanks to the knowledge graph, data.world can produce interactive lineage visualizations that show how data flows through systems. Users can explore upstream and downstream relationships of a data asset easily, seeing the web of connections emanating from, say, a particular table or report. This lineage isn’t limited to technical ETL jobs; it also can encompass business relationships (like which department owns the data) because of the unified graph.
data.world supports governance needs by allowing the definition of governance rules and linking them into the knowledge graph. The knowledge graph also means business glossaries and technical metadata are integrated, ensuring that governance has the full context (e.g., a term in the glossary can be tied to actual data elements it pertains to).
What are the drawbacks of data.world?
Integration and customization challenges
Additional effort is required for some integrations. Connecting less common or highly custom data sources may require more effort or custom development. While many standard connectors exist, if your stack includes a homegrown data system or an unusual legacy database, you might need to build a connector using data.world’s API.
Internally, data.world’s use of a knowledge graph means it might introduce new concepts (like graph query languages or ontology management) that are unfamiliar to some teams. While users of the catalog interface don’t need to know these details, administrators or power users might need to understand the graph model to fully leverage advanced features.
Documentation and support limitations
Some users have reported difficulties in finding comprehensive documentation or receiving timely support from data.world’s team when issues arise. As a newer platform that is evolving rapidly, documentation might not always keep pace with the latest features, leaving users to experiment or reach out to support for clarification. In cases where support is slow to respond, this can be frustrating if you’re blocked on a task.
data.world’s user community, while growing, is smaller than those of older, more established catalog products. This means there are fewer third-party resources (blogs, forums, how-to guides) available. If official documentation is lacking, you cannot as readily turn to a large community of experts for answers. The company is actively improving documentation and support, but at present, this can be a minor weakness compared to the robust user communities behind some competitor tools.
Despite these drawbacks, data.world is increasingly recognized for its innovative approach. Many users appreciate that its benefits in discovery and collaboration outweigh these relatively minor limitations.
data.world: Pros and cons
Pros
Knowledge graph architecture provides superior data context
AI-powered automation enhances metadata management
Intuitive, user-friendly interface encourages adoption
Advanced search capabilities improve data discovery
Strong collaboration features for team-based data projects
Cons
Governance features are not as extensive as some competitors
Requires additional effort for integrating non-standard data sources
Graph-based metadata modeling may have a learning curve
Some users report documentation and support could be improved
Atlan: Streamlining data collaboration
Atlan is a modern data collaboration platform designed to streamline how teams work with data. It functions as an active metadata-powered data catalog, unifying data discovery, governance, and quality in one place.
Organizations use Atlan to centralize their data assets and metadata, so users can easily find the data they need along with context like definitions and ownership. A key selling point of Atlan is its active metadata framework – the platform automatically ingests and updates metadata as data workloads run, keeping the catalog up-to-date without extensive manual effort. In short, Atlan’s goal is to make data assets searchable, understandable, and collaborative for everyone in an organization.
Beyond cataloging, Atlan integrates into the broader data ecosystem to support end-to-end data operations. It offers comprehensive data lineage tracking, allowing users to trace the origin and journey of data through pipelines. This lineage capability helps with auditing and impact analysis – for example, if a source table changes, teams can identify downstream dashboards or models that might be affected.
Atlan includes basic data governance features such as a business glossary and policy management, so companies can define governance rules and link them to data assets to ensure compliance and consistency. Atlan was built to work with the modern analytics stack. Overall, Atlan’s combination of active metadata, user-friendly search, lineage, and integration with existing tools makes it a compelling choice for teams seeking a collaborative data catalog.
Atlan excels in its active metadata capabilities when compared to data.world. See what data.world users say about the platform.
Features and benefits of Atlan
Atlan provides an “active metadata” layer that automatically ingests metadata from data pipelines as they run. This means whenever datasets are created or modified in connected systems, Atlan pulls in those changes.
By automating metadata collection and updates, Atlan lessens the burden on data stewards. Teams spend less time curating metadata and more time using data.
Data discovery and collaboration
Atlan’s interface is designed to be intuitive, with powerful search and filter capabilities that let users quickly find relevant data assets. Users can search by keywords, apply facets (like data source or owner), and get instant results. Additionally, Atlan supports custom categorization and tagging of assets, so organizations can organize data in a way that aligns with their business terms and taxonomy.
Atlan encourages collaboration by allowing users to contribute context and knowledge to the catalog. For example, users can add documentation, comments, or Q&A to data asset pages. Atlan also integrates with collaboration platforms such as Slack, so stakeholders can get notifications or discuss data assets in their usual communication channels.
Data lineage and context
Atlan offers comprehensive data lineage capabilities, allowing users to trace the origin, movement, and transformation of data from source to downstream consumption. The platform can display lineage graphs that show how tables are linked by ETL processes, how datasets feed into dashboards or machine learning models, and so on.
By having visibility into the data’s journey, stakeholders can trust the data more. Atlan’s lineage includes details on transformations and touchpoints, which supports compliance and auditing efforts.
Integration with modern data stack
Atlan is built to plug into modern data environments seamlessly. It comes with connectors for popular databases, data warehouses (like Snowflake, BigQuery), data lakes, and BI tools, enabling it to pull in metadata from all these sources. Atlan essentially becomes a single window into all data assets across the enterprise.
For any source that isn’t supported out of the box, Atlan provides RESTful APIs so teams can programmatically integrate custom data sources or build extensions. Many organizations have leveraged this to integrate Atlan with their niche internal tools.
Data governance and compliance
Atlan includes features to support data governance initiatives. Teams can define data policies (e.g. data retention rules, access policies) and link them to data assets in the catalog. It also offers a business glossary where key business terms, metrics, and definitions can be documented and related to physical data sources.
The platform enables assigning ownership or stewardship for data assets, which clarifies accountability. Data stewards can be tasked with reviewing assets or approving changes. While Atlan may not have the most advanced built-in data quality tooling, it does allow integration with data quality tools and can store data quality metrics as part of asset metadata.
What are the drawbacks of Atlan?
One notable drawback is that Atlan’s AI and machine learning powered features are not available in the base offering and require additional purchase. For example, if a team wants AI-driven recommendations or automated metadata tagging from Atlan, they might have to pay extra fees. Rigid governance workflows
Atlan provides automation for data governance (such as workflows for certifications or approvals), but these workflows are reported to be relatively rigid and hard to tailor to specific business needs.
Relatedly, Atlan lacks a centralized task management or notification system for governance activities. For instance, if data stewards need to review certain assets or if owners must certify a dataset, Atlan doesn’t provide a unified dashboard to see all pending tasks or send in-app reminders.
Limited collaboration on DataOps
While Atlan integrates with many tools, it currently lacks dedicated features for DataOps collaboration, such as pipeline monitors or issue management for data workflows. If a data pipeline fails or a data quality issue arises, Atlan doesn’t have a native way for teams to flag the issue, discuss it within the platform, or track it to resolution. This is a missed opportunity to tie data cataloging with operational data workflows.
Lineage visualization constraints
Although Atlan offers data lineage, users have noted that the lineage visualizations are relatively basic and not highly customizable. The platform can show straightforward source-to-target relationships, but it may struggle to represent more complex data flow scenarios or conditional logic in ETL processes.
In cases of very large or complex pipelines, the lineage graph in Atlan can become hard to navigate, and the level of detail might be insufficient for deep analysis. For example, Atlan might not let you overlay additional info (like data quality metrics or transformation code) directly on the lineage diagram. Teams requiring in-depth lineage analysis and customization may find this limiting.
High maintenance overhead
Atlan’s promise of active metadata works well in straightforward environments, but in very complex, enterprise data landscapes, setting up and maintaining Atlan’s metadata ingestion can require significant effort. Users report that configuring numerous connectors and ensuring all metadata stays in sync is resource-intensive. If an organization has a wide variety of sources and a high volume of changes, Atlan’s backend processes for pulling in metadata can consume notable time and computing resources.
As a result, companies might need dedicated personnel or effort to manage Atlan’s integrations and ingestion jobs. Any changes in source systems (new platforms, API changes, etc.) require updates to the Atlan connectors.
Search limitations
Metadata search could be stronger. Despite Atlan’s easy interface, some users find the search functionality on metadata to be weaker than expected. For instance, search results might not always rank the most relevant data asset at the top, especially in catalogs with vast content.
Discoverability challenges mean that the very feature that is supposed to speed up discovery can sometimes slow users down if they struggle to formulate the right query. Non-technical users, in particular, might get frustrated if the search requires precise terms.
Complicated permission management
Managing permissions and access in Atlan can become complicated when dealing with many user groups and roles. Enterprises often need to grant different levels of access to different teams (for example, analysts can view and request access to data, data stewards can edit metadata, etc.)
Furthermore, Atlan’s permission model may lack some granularity. Companies have unique requirements—some might want to restrict who can see certain sensitive metadata, or allow a user to edit descriptions but not change classifications. Meeting such nuanced requirements might involve workarounds in Atlan.
Despite these drawbacks, Atlan remains a popular choice due to its strengths in usability and integration. However, it’s important to weigh these limitations against the needs of your organization.
Atlan: Pros and cons
Pros
Offers active metadata and automation to keep catalogs up to date
User-friendly interface with strong collaboration features
Seamless integrations with modern data stacks
Built-in data lineage visualization
Cons
AI capabilities require additional costs
Governance workflows lack customization
Search capabilities could be stronger
Permission management can be complex
Data catalogs have become essential for managing enterprise data assets, with Atlan and data.world emerging as notable platforms in this space.
Atlan focuses on dynamic access controls and self-service capabilities that appeal particularly to technical users and data engineers, offering rapid deployment with minimal friction.
Data.world, built on a knowledge graph foundation, emphasizes connecting technical metadata with business context and leverages AI to enhance accuracy and automate catalog management.
While both support modern data stacks and governance initiatives, they differentiate through their architectural approaches; Atlan with its technical accessibility and data.world with its semantic understanding and AI-powered features.
In summary, data.world outperforms Atlan in areas of automation, flexibility, and intelligent data context. Through its native knowledge graph architecture, data.world addresses many of the limitations users might encounter with Atlan.
Evaluating data catalog vendors? Use the Data Catalog RFI Template to evaluate options and make a data-driven decision.
An industry-leading data catalog with unmatched technical abilities
Trusted by over 2 million users worldwide, data.world stands as the market's most widely adopted data catalog solution
Powered by knowledge graph architecture, data.world delivers query results with 3x greater accuracy than conventional data catalogs
Unlike traditional solutions, data.world's unique knowledge graph foundation visualizes all elements, from metadata and tables to documents, as interconnected nodes with defined relationships.
Discover why leading data teams choose data.world—schedule your personalized demo today.
